Top Stories Of The Day

Brand New Max Payne 3 Screens Hit The Web And Are Action-Packed

Rockstar unveiled some new screens from their anticipated title, Max Payne 3, which features the new Max, doing what he does best.

Final Fantasy VII Downloaded 100,000 Times In Two Weeks

The classic PS1 RPG breaks fastest-selling PSN records within two weeks of its availability.

Uncharted 2 Wins Three E3 09' Game Critics Awards Including 'Best Of Show'

The Game Critics Awards, which compiles rankings from 29 of the most well-known media outlets, has announced the Best of E3 2009 winners.

'Faster' Xbox Live Dashboard In Next Update Confirms Major Nelson

Larry Hryb revealed that he and the Live team will be working to make a "faster" guide coming soon to the next proper dashboard update.

Street Fighter II Turbo HD Remix: Xbox Live Deal Of The Week

Looks like the deals keep coming, as it was revealed that their deal of the week is Super Street Figheter II Turbo HD Remix.

Get more action in Conviction

VIDEO: Find out why Splinter Cell Conviction is more brutal than any other stealth game. Click here for the video!



My Nintendo Wii Downloads

Check out the newly added "My Nintendo Wii Downloads" page and learn how to play games on your Nintendo Wii for Free! We show you step by step how to put the Homebrew Channel onto your Wii in vivid detail including video tutorials, downloads and much more! Check out the new page here!

Sports Legends Father's Day Gift Guide!

Father's Day is almost here and Sports Legends has the toys and tech to make your dad feel like the man! Click here for the exclusive guide!



E3 2009 Preview Explosion

You may have missed a few, so check out our expanding lineup of E3 previews and news! Click here for all of our E3 2009 coverage!
reflection.js


Quick-Jump To A Screenshot Gallery

Nov 9, 2008

Little Big Planet Levels Being Deleted Due To Copyright Issues

I'm reading: Little Big Planet Levels Being Deleted Due To Copyright IssuesTweet this!


Complaints are growing about levels being "moderated" out of existence.


Before saving your cutsom created map in Little Big Planet, make sure that it doesn't contain copyrighted material

It seems Guitar Hero World Tour isn't the only game dealing with copyright infringements. As Kotaku reports, complaints are spreading across the official Little Big Planet forum, with players' arguing that their custom levels are being "moderated" -- or, to use less euphemistic language, "deleted forevermore" -- without warning or much explanation from Media Molecule. But there seems to be one common thread tying together many of the deleted levels: use of copyrighted materials.

"This just happened to tons of levels in what seems like a matter of minutes, including my own level 'Failure To Launch,'" wrote one user in a Little Big Workshop thread. "By the trend I see from the levels I can no longer play from my recent levels on my planet, it's all about copyright. Some levels I've seen [that are] now unplayable due to moderation: Pacman, Batman, and Scrubs related level."


Indeed, these players have had to piece together this "trend," as one of the bigger problems is a lack of explanation from Media Molecule when a level is deleted. "We're reviewing the moderating system currently to provide better feedback on why levels are moderated," a Media Molecule developer later wrote in that same thread. "Primarily, any level that is reported using the grief tool will be checked over by a moderator, at which point they'll examine it in line with the [End User License Agreement]. If a level is found to be in violation of the EULA it will be moderated and you'll receive a message to that effect. We're moving towards a system where additional information is given, however for the time being if you don't want your level moderating avoid anything unsuitable for users of all ages and copyright content."

Another problem with Media Molecule's system is that it doesn't give a user a chance to change whatever copyrighted (or otherwise delete-worthy) material exists in their level in order to keep the rest of the level online; the whole thing simply gets deleted entirely, and users can't alter and re-host them. This has already spurred at least one user to figure out a workaround, explaining that you can copy a created level to another slot of your "My Moon" page, and host the original version. If that version then gets deleted, you'll still have a second version to alter and try to re-host.

While it's understandable that copyrighted materials would be barred from use in players' levels, the main problem here seems to be a lack of consistency and fairness -- you can imagine how frustrating it could be to spend hours working on a perfectly envisioned level, only to have it deleted without warning because, as one player wrote, they had a Metal Gear Solid character appearing in it. Hopefully Media Molecule will come through soon, and get a better "moderating" system in place.

And really, even when it does come to the use of copyrighted materials, you kind of have to wonder: If Burnout Paradise can not (wink, wink) add the Back to the Future Time Machine into their game, surely there can be some leniency in what can and can't be used in Little Big Planet? We imagine a level containing the image of a vaguely familiar super spy wearing a bandana and eye patch and smoking a cigarette, with a large sign over his head that helpfully identifies him as "Not Solid Snake."

2 Comments:

Yzzlthtz said...

hmm, then why are there still like hundreds of levels based on franchises??? god of war titled level is still up, many mgs levels are still up, and more...
i smell some mild deception.
level deleting may be happening, but i don't think it's as bad as this article makes it out to be.

Anonymous said...

I think it's mainly based off of movie franchises not so much games.

Post a Comment